Why Supplier Diversity Reporting Matters
Supplier diversity reporting is the foundation of any successful supplier diversity program. Without accurate measurement, you can't manage, improve, or demonstrate the impact of your diversity initiatives.
Stakeholder Accountability
Reports demonstrate commitment to boards, investors, and community stakeholders who increasingly expect transparency on ESG metrics.
Contract Compliance
Government and corporate contracts often require specific diverse spend percentages. Accurate reporting ensures compliance.
Program Improvement
Data-driven insights help identify gaps, set realistic goals, and measure the effectiveness of supplier diversity initiatives.
Economic Impact
Quantify the economic contribution your diverse spend makes to communities and diverse business growth.
Tier 1 vs Tier 2 Reporting
Understanding the difference between Tier 1 and Tier 2 spend is fundamental to supplier diversity reporting.
Tier 1 (Direct Spend)
Definition: Purchases made directly from diverse suppliers by your organization.
- You pay the diverse supplier directly
- Easier to track and verify
- Full control over supplier selection
- Most common reporting requirement
Tier 2 (Indirect Spend)
Definition: Diverse spend by your prime suppliers in their subcontracting or supply chains.
- Your supplier pays diverse vendors
- Requires supplier cooperation to track
- Extends impact through supply chain
- Increasingly required by large buyers
Why Tier 2 Matters
Many categories (e.g., large IT projects, construction) have few diverse prime contractors but many diverse subcontractors. Tier 2 reporting captures this impact and encourages prime suppliers to develop their own diverse supply chains.
Key Metrics & KPIs
Track these metrics to measure and demonstrate supplier diversity program success:
| Metric | Description | Target Range |
|---|---|---|
| Total Diverse Spend | Dollar amount spent with certified diverse suppliers | Varies by industry |
| Diverse Spend % | Diverse spend as % of addressable spend | 10-20%+ typical goal |
| Supplier Count | Number of diverse suppliers used | Growth year over year |
| Avg Spend/Supplier | Average spend per diverse supplier | Indicates depth of relationships |
| Category Penetration | % of categories with diverse suppliers | Broader is better |
| Certification Mix | Breakdown by MBE, WBE, VBE, LGBTBE, etc. | Varies by goals |
Certification Categories to Track
Avoid Double Counting
A supplier can hold multiple certifications (e.g., MBE + WBE). When reporting by category, count the spend once per category. When reporting total diverse spend, count the supplier's spend only once to avoid inflation.
Data Collection Best Practices
Establish Baseline Data
Start by documenting your current diverse spend to measure improvement. Identify addressable spend categories and current diverse suppliers.
Integrate with Procurement Systems
Flag diverse suppliers in your ERP/procurement system with certification type and expiration date. Automate spend tracking where possible.
Verify Certifications
Request copies of current certifications. Set up alerts for expiration dates. Use certification databases (NMSDC, WBENC, SAM.gov) to verify status.
Collect Tier 2 Data
Require prime suppliers to report diverse subcontracting. Include reporting requirements in contracts. Provide templates for consistency.
Regular Reconciliation
Reconcile supplier diversity data with AP data monthly or quarterly. Investigate discrepancies promptly.
Data Quality Checklist
- Certification copies on file and current
- Supplier taxonomy consistent (one record per supplier)
- Spend categories clearly defined
- Addressable vs. non-addressable spend identified
- Parent/subsidiary relationships documented
- Tier 2 reporting templates standardized
Compliance Requirements
Different sectors have varying supplier diversity reporting requirements:
Federal Government
Federal contractors must report small and disadvantaged business subcontracting through the eSRS (Electronic Subcontracting Reporting System) if the contract exceeds thresholds.
- Individual Subcontracting Reports (ISRs)
- Summary Subcontracting Reports (SSRs)
- Required for contracts over $750,000 ($1.5M construction)
State & Local Government
Requirements vary by jurisdiction. Common requirements include:
- Monthly or quarterly spend reports
- Good faith effort documentation
- Utilization plans
- Payment verification
Utilities (California)
CPUC-regulated utilities must report annually through GO 156:
- Women, Minority, Disabled Veteran spend
- Both Tier 1 and Tier 2
- Annual reports due March 1
Corporate (Voluntary)
Many corporations set internal goals and report in:
- Annual ESG/CSR reports
- CDP Climate disclosures
- GRI sustainability reports
- Customer-required reports
Reporting Tools & Templates
Software Solutions
Several software platforms specialize in supplier diversity tracking:
- Supplier.io: Comprehensive spend analytics and diverse supplier identification
- Coupa: Procurement platform with diversity tracking capabilities
- Ariba: Supplier management with diversity module
- B2GNow: Popular for government contract compliance
- Tealbook: Supplier data and diversity intelligence
Basic Reporting Template
At minimum, your supplier diversity report should include:
-
Executive Summary
- Total diverse spend and % of addressable
- Year-over-year comparison
- Progress toward goals
-
Spend by Certification Category
- MBE, WBE, VBE, SDVOSB, LGBTBE, DOBE breakdown
- Tier 1 vs Tier 2 split
-
Spend by Business Category
- Top categories by diverse spend
- Opportunities for growth
-
Supplier Analysis
- Number of diverse suppliers
- Top diverse suppliers by spend
- New suppliers added
-
Program Initiatives
- Outreach events attended
- Mentorship programs
- Supplier development activities
Common Challenges & Solutions
Challenge: Expired Certifications
Impact: Spend can't be counted if certification lapses.
Solution: Implement 90-day advance alerts. Include recertification assistance in supplier development programs.
Challenge: Supplier Won't Self-Identify
Impact: Missing diverse spend in reports.
Solution: Use third-party databases for identification. Explain benefits of registration. Streamline your registration process.
Challenge: Tier 2 Data Quality
Impact: Inaccurate or incomplete subcontractor reporting.
Solution: Contractual requirements, standardized templates, periodic audits, and Tier 2 reporting incentives.
Challenge: Defining Addressable Spend
Impact: Inflated or deflated percentages.
Solution: Establish clear criteria (e.g., exclude intercompany, utilities, taxes). Document methodology consistently.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is "addressable spend" and why does it matter?
Addressable spend is the portion of your total spend where you have flexibility to choose suppliers. It excludes categories where diverse suppliers don't exist or where you have no choice (e.g., taxes, utilities, intercompany transfers, sole-source contracts).
Reporting diverse spend as a percentage of addressable spend (rather than total spend) gives a more accurate picture of program performance. A company with 10% diverse spend against addressable spend is performing better than one with 5% against total spend if the first has less addressable opportunity.
Should I count P-card or credit card purchases?
Yes, if you can track them. P-card spend with diverse suppliers should be included. Challenges include:
- Merchant category codes may not identify diverse vendors
- Small dollar amounts may not justify tracking effort
- Employee purchases may bypass procurement controls
Best practice: Flag known diverse merchants in your P-card system. For smaller programs, focus first on larger PO-based spend.
How do I handle joint ventures with diverse suppliers?
For joint ventures (JVs), you can typically count the percentage of the JV that is diverse-owned. For example, if a diverse supplier owns 40% of a JV that receives $1M in spend, you could report $400,000 as diverse spend.
However, requirements vary by reporting entity. Federal contracts have specific rules for mentor-protégé JVs. Always verify the rules for your specific reporting requirements.
What if a supplier loses certification mid-year?
Generally, you can count spend that occurred while the certification was valid. Spend after the certification expires cannot be counted as diverse spend.
This is why certification tracking and renewal alerts are critical. Work with suppliers to ensure continuous certification, or reclassify them as non-diverse in your system when certifications lapse.
How do I report when a diverse supplier is acquired by a non-diverse company?
Once a diverse supplier is acquired and no longer meets ownership criteria, they typically lose diverse status. This is called "certification graduation" or "acquired out."
For reporting purposes:
- Count spend as diverse up to acquisition date
- Reclassify as non-diverse after acquisition
- Document the change for audit purposes
Need Help With Your Supplier Diversity Program?
Connect with certified diverse suppliers ready to help your organization meet its supplier diversity goals.